II The Tragic Journey - Abduction and Enslavement of the Boat People
These Vietnamese women had hidden from the pirates in caves on Khra Island
for fear of being raped. They had been forced to stand in knee deep sea water
for days, during which sea crabs ate away much of the flesh of their feet and
legs.
The worst nightmare became a dreadful reality when the
buccaneers forcibly kidnapped the helpless women. From that point onward, the
surviving refugees would have to live with a guilty conscience because they
could not protect the disappeared victims. They constantly wondered why they
risked their lives to take their loved ones to face oceanic dangers and
eventually a disastrous doom. They felt at fault because they did not die in
their protest against the pirates’ seizure of the defenseless women.
In
the first six months of 1981, there were 701 pirates’ attacks on the boat
people and more than 145 reported kidnapping cases. One of the survivors in
Songkhla Refugee Camp is Ms. Nguyễn Phương Thúy, aged 15. Her
baby sister named Trân and she left Vietnam with 66 others on a 33-feet-long
boat on May 19, 1981. Forty hours later, the boat was savagely raided by Thai
buccaneers. After taking all valuables from the refugees and seizing Ms.
Nguyễn and another female, the pirates steered their huge ship to slam
into the small Vietnamese craft and killed all people remaining on board
including little Trân. During the following 3 ½ months, Ms. Nguyễn and
the other woman were held captive as sex slaves and were repeatedly raped
everyday. The kidnappers then sold them to other Thai ships in exchange for
fishes; the victims were changed hands at least 14 times. Eventually, the 15th
ship dumped them on a beach where they were subsequently arrested and held by
Thai authorities as illegal aliens. In prison, Ms. Nguyễn met another
unfortunate female victim named Nguyễn Thị Lan, aged 25, who was
also kept as a sex slave on an island off the coast of Thailand for many days.
After her release to Songkhla Refugee Camp, because of her dire experience, Ms.
Nguyễn wrote letters home to plead with her mother and aunts not to leave
Socialist Vietnam by boat. Ironically, Ms. Nguyễn Phương Thúy
was prohibited by Thai authorities - supposedly implementing an anti-piracy program at that time - to
speak to reporters about her dreadful journey.
The list of abducted
victims is endless. Ðinh Ngọc
Lệ Thủy, born February 22, 1967, was kidnapped by Thai
pirates on December 8, 1986 in front of her mother;
her mother now lives in Garden Grove, California. Dư Tuyết
Mỹ, born January 20, 1962, was abducted at sea on March 13, 1982.
Nguyễn Thị Diễm, born December 25, 1966, was kidnapped in the
Gulf of Thailand on February 16, 1984. Phạm Thị Khuê Lương,
born January 1, 1967, and Phạm Thị Yến Ly, born October 26,
1968, left Rạch Giá port on May 24, 1988 and were taken away by Thai
pirates on May 27, 1988. In the case of Tăng Bích Hằng, her family
offers an unconditional reward of U.S. $10,000 for information leading to her
whereabouts.
A
large number of refugee boats like this one never reached
the
destination of freedom after being savagely raided by
cruel
pirates or tossed by massive waves.
At
least 80,000 to 200,000 boat people vanished at sea.
We
do not know how many young Vietnamese girls and women were kidnapped by the
pirates, but we can be certain that the number is horrendous. Among the victims
known to have disappeared in their request for freedom are Tăng Bích
Hằng, Nguyễn Thị Thu Nguyệt, Phạm Ngọc Bích
Thủy, Võ Thị Cẩm Nhung, Nguyễn Thị Mỹ Dung,
Phạm Thị Ngọc Bích, Phạm Thị Ngọc
Hạnh, Nguyễn Thị Ngọc
Anh, Diệp Mỹ Linh, Nguyễn Thị Hiền, Hoàng
Thị Kim Chi and Hoàng Thị Kim Dung, Quách Lê Nương, Lê Thị Kim Hồng,
Huỳnh Kim Phụng, Ðinh Thị Như, Nguyễn Thị Ðắc
Tâm, Nhữ Thị Thiên Kim, Vũ Thị Thanh Thảo,
Nguyễn Thanh Thủy, Ðặng Thị Quỳnh Hoa, Ðặng
Thị Quỳnh Như, Tiến Xuân Mai, Nguyễn Thị
Cẩm Hồng, Bửu Nghị Liêu, Ðỗ Hoàng Dung, Vũ
Xuân Phụng, Nguyễn Diễm Hương, Võ Thị
Tuyết, Bảo Trân, Tạ Thị Kim Hoàn,
Trần Mỹ Hằng, Lệ Nguyễn Trúc Mai,
Phạm Thị Sương Liễu, Phạm Thị Trúc Ly,
Phạm Thị Ngọc Luyện, Châu Yến Linh, Trần Bích
Thủy, Trần Thị Mỹ, Ngô Thị Liễu, Tống
Mỹ Hạnh, Nguyễn Thị Kiều Dung, Nguyễn
Thị Kiều Phương, etc.
The
abducted victims were usually murdered after being sexually assaulted by the
pirates, who often tried to destroy all evidence of their criminal activities.
In a few cases, the victims were known to have been sold into prostitution. In
one reported incident, Ms. Nguyễn Thị Trương was
kidnapped, raped repeatedly and then forced to work as a prostitute at the
Heavenly Pleasure Massage Club in Southern Thailand.[1]
In
another case, Ms. Nguyễn Ánh Tuyết and her sister Nguyễn
Thị Nam left Nha Trang on December 8, 1979. During the course of the
journey, 12 children died after the boat ran out of fuel and fresh water. On
December 21, the desperate refugees encountered two pirate ships. Ms.
Nguyễn Thị Nam was clubbed by the Thai buccaneers to death and
thrown overboard. After the violent robbery, the victims were taken to Khra
Island where they were kept as slaves. Three young girls continued to be held
captive on the pirate ships. One of
the three young women, Ms. Lan, was detained on the first ship, and her fate
remained unknown. Ms. Nguyễn Ánh Tuyết, aged 17, and Ms. Công
Huyền Tôn Nữ Mỹ Kiều, aged 17, were eventually taken by
the second ship’s kidnappers to a hotel in Songkhla. When one of the
buccaneers tried to rape her, Ms. Nguyễn Ánh Tuyết screamed aloud.
Her cries attracted the attention of nearby tourists, who quickly intervened and
rescued her. Eventually, the Thai authorities got involved and secured the two
women’s release. Upon apprehension, the pirates admitted that they were
planning to sell the captive victims into the sex trade in Songkhla.
As for many other refugees, they were enslaved on several
isolated and inhabited isles off the eastern coast of southern Thailand, one of
which was Koh Khra (Freckle Island) 43
miles from Phak Phanang District. Koh
Khra was hell on earth for a large number of boat people, who were abducted and
taken there by Thai pirates. The sea terrors took the unfortunate refugees to
Khra Island after destroying their boats and kept them prisoners. The
defenseless victims had no mean to escape and were isolated completely; they
soon became dependent totally on the buccaneers for food and fresh water.
Once
the helpless refugees were taken to Khra Island, all buccaneers quickly learned
about the presence of the new prisoners from radioed information sent by the
kidnappers. Thereafter, several
fishing ships stopped by the isle daily to rape the women and young girls; some
of these victims just turned eleven or twelve years old. As soon as the captive
refugees saw the pirates’ colorful ships appearing on the skyline, they fled
and tried to hide themselves in cages or bushes.
They were terrified by the daily atrocious conducts, and thus many went
deep into the wood to avoid the bandits. Others hid themselves in small caves
filled with salt water; their feet were nipped by sea crabs, but they had to
swallow the pains because they feared the pirates more than anything else on
earth. When the brutal fishermen came to the isle, they quickly turned into
savage man hunters. They searched the wood and tortured the unlucky victims to
find out others’ whereabouts. The cycle of violence and rapes reoccurred once
again.
Fortunately, rescues by the UNHCR occasionally arrived. The evacuated
Asylees were subsequently taken to refugee camps for medical care. A large
number of women and teenage girls had to be transferred to Thai hospitals
whereby only sophisticated medical techniques and drugs could save their lives.
Many victims faced severe psychological problems as a result of the hellish
experience that they underwent on Khra Island.[2]
Despite how hard they tried to forget the ordeal, the nightmares still remained
visible in their mind and continuously haunted them daily.
The Koh Khra incidents were many and well-documented.[3] In one case, Mrs.
Nguyễn Thị Thưởng and her family left on boat no. SS0640
IA on December 1, 1979. The vessel
carrying 107 people was robed by Thai pirates, who then took the victims to Koh
Khra. The men were forced to swim to shore from a far distance, and 7 of them
consequently drowned. During their 8-day ordeal on the island, the women were
raped and the men were tortured repeatedly. On the 3rd day, a patrol
boat no. POLICE#513 anchored a few meters from shore and noticed their loud call
for help but did not respond. The pirates came back the following days and
continued their savage attack on the captive refugees. Eventually, the
unfortunate victims were rescued by a UNHCR team and transferred to Songkhla
Refugee Camp in Thailand.
With
international aid, Bangkok set up an observatory station on Khra Island in 1981
to save enslaved victims. During a 12-month period, 1250 boat persons were
evacuated from Koh Khra, where 160 other unfortunate victims died before help
arrived. A UNHCR report described some of the horrible scenes on the isle:[4]
‘One woman was severely burned when the
pirates set fire to the hillside where she was hiding in an attempt to flush her
out. Another cowed for days in a
cave, waist-deep in water, until crabs had torn the skin and much of the flesh
away from her legs. A young girl
who died after being gang raped is buried under a simple slab at the edge of a
clearing.’
In
1980, a 2-month study taken by the boat people at Songkhla Refugee Camp shows
the following horrific statistics:
|
1980 |
May
|
June |
|
Arriving boats |
41 |
36 |
|
Arrivals were robed |
36 (88%) |
35 (97%) |
|
Arrivals taken to
Koh Khra |
5 (12%) |
1 (3%) |
|
Female arrivers
|
384 |
440 |
|
Arriving rape victims |
92 (24%) |
55 (13%) |
|
Known victims
who died or lost at sea |
70 |
3 |
Khra Island was not the only hell for the boat people. A temporary camp
named Kuku on Jemaja Island was another hell within the Indonesian territories.
On this island where Vietnamese arrivers were held temporarily in military tents
before their refugee-screening interview and subsequent transfer to other
centers such as Pulau Galang refugee camp, Indonesian soldiers often kidnapped
female Asylees and gang raped the victims at nights between 1989 and 1990.[5]
According to Ms. Nguyễn Thị Thủy, a boat person encamped in
Kuku camp now residing in Toronto, Canada, the victims and their families did
not dare to complain to international agencies because they feared for their
safety. The calamity was unfolded only after a female victim’s uncle was
beaten to death by Indonesian soldiers when he resisted their beast-like raid;
the uncle’s terrible fate sparked diplomatic intervention and eventually ended
the Indonesian savage grip on the defenseless refugees.[6]
Khra
and Jemaja Islands were certainly not the only isles whereon the boat people
were detained, enslaved, raped and murdered. How many other Khra and Jemaja
Islands were there in the Gulf of Thailand? There were at least 52 islands
frequented by the pirates, but the local authorities showed no interest in any
prolonged search and rescue mission to evacuate Vietnamese refugees from these
hellish islands. The official policy was clearly to prevent the Asylees’
arrival rather than to stop piracy; and therefore, various international
observers rightly speculated that the pirates and other criminal elements were
encouraged by their government’s acquiescence to deter all
Vietnamese boat people from reaching safety.
[1]
Bangkok
Post, 9 September 1979.
[2]
Mental illnesses affected not
only the Khra victims but
also other terrified survivors. For
example, by late 1979 on Bidong Island in Malaysia, there were at least 28
Vietnamese refugees, mostly rape victims, diagnosed with serious mental
problems.
[3]
For documented cases, please refer to Nhat Tien, Duong Phuc, Vu Thanh
Thuy, Pirates on the Gulf of Siam,
2nd Edi., Boat People S.O.S. Committee, San Diego 1981.
[4]
Quoted in Barry Wain, The Refused: The Agony of
the Indochina Refugees, supra, at p. 71.
[6]
Interview with Ms. Nguyễn Thị Thủy on November 30,
1998 at Lloyd Duong Attorneys Atrium
in Toronto, Canada. Ms.
Nguyễn Thị Thủy was permitted to enter Canada on October
20, 1992 on humanitarian grounds as a result of the Kuku incidence.